Best Craft Lights & Lamps: Reviews 2020

When you are working on something, the one thing you need in abundance is good light. Without the right light, you won’t be able to fully concentrate on the project at hand, let alone do them properly. 

It is always the best to concentrate on your crafting in natural light, during the day, when you get the most light to work with.

However, if you happen to be more comfortable working in the afternoon or at night, or if you don’t have enough time during the day, what you need is the help of the best craft light for your craft table. Your wall lights are not going to be enough for your crafting, especially if you are working with needles and threads, or tiny pieces. 

Buying a craft light for your craft tables isn’t a very complicated decision, but you still need to focus on a few details before you get the one that’s perfect for you. 

Top 11 Craft Lights On Your Budget

Below are brief descriptions of some of the most popular crafting lights that are available in the market at the moment. Any one of these, or more, could be the right one for your crafting table. 

1. Brightech Litespan LED Reading and Craft Floor Lamp

Even if there’s no space left on your craft table, you can still use this lamp from Brightech Litespan beside your table. This is a standing floor lamp that you can use anywhere in your house, not just your crafting. It’s so lightweight, you can take the same lamp with you to the other rooms of your home, wherever you are working on your craft.

If you want to take your sewing or bullet journaling to your bedroom or your living room, you can also take the lamp with you for proper lighting. 

The design is slim and modern, and will perfectly fit in with your room’s decor. It takes a very small space on your floor, beside your crafting table, so it won’t be a big bother for you. This LED lamp gives you a natural light, and it is a 6,000k cool white light with an output of 2,000 lumens.

It comes with a 12 watt LED light that saves power and will last for 20 years without the need for changing. You will never have to replace a single bulb inside this lamp or repair it for as long as you are using it. 

With the Litespan LED lamp from Brightech, you get 5 color option of light, and a gooseneck that you can bend and point anywhere you want the light to be. With the built-in dimmer, you can increase and decrease the intensity of the light.

The light stays cool even after hours of use, which means that you won’t accidentally burn yourself by touching it. 

Important Features:

  • 6,000k cool white light 
  • 2,000 lumens output 
  • Comes with a 12 watt LED light 
  • Will last for 20 years without need for changing bulb 
  • 5 color option of light
  • Dimmable light 
  • Light doesn’t get hot 
  • Lightweight and can be moved from room to room 
  • Slim and modern design 
  • Doesn’t take a lot of space on your floor 
  • Doesn’t increase electricity bill 
  • Gives natural daylight 

2. TaoTronics LED Desk Lamp  

All you need is a little space on your crafting table for this lamp; it has a slim design that will give you a strong, useful light without too much cluttering.

It comes with 5 color options for you to choose from, as well as 7 brightness levels. You can use this table lamp not just at your crafting table, but also for reading and working, and beside your bed. 

This lamp comes with energy efficient LED lights, which won’t affect negatively on your electricity bill. Your electricity bill will remain the same even after daily use of this lamp for hours.

You can cast the perfect light on your project, by swivelling the lamp 45 degrees or tilting it up and down by 150 degrees. You can move the light in multiple ways and use it the best way you want the light to fall on your project at hand. 

This LED table lamp comes with a portable charging USB port; you can charge your phone with this lamp at all time when you are at your crafting table. 

Important Features:

  • Slim and modern-design for your craft table 
  • Doesn’t take up a lot of space 
  • Can be swiveled and tilted in a number of directions 
  • 5 color options 
  • 7 brightness levels 
  • Comes with a USB charging port 
  • Won’t build up your electricity bill 
  • Ideal for working, reading and crafting 
  • Flicker-free light 
  • Naturally bright light 

3. Vekkia Rechargeable 4 LED Book Light  

This is a completely different type of light for all your crafting time - a lamp that you can wear around your neck, wherever you are. This LED light is perfect not just for reading, but also for sewing, journaling and any other kind of crafting you are interested in.

Wear them around your neck, and you can move the two bulbs in any direction you want to, to give light at any point in front of you. It’s like wearing a headlight on your forehead, but better.

You won’t have to keep your head nodding just to focus your light on the point you want to, but simply adjust the lamp on your neck. 

With this rechargeable neck lamp, you can read, write or work anywhere you want to, even someplace you have no access to an electrical socket.

If you want to work in your garden, backyard or patio at night or in the evening, all you need is this neck lamp around you. You can even go on working on your bed while your partner sleeps next to you uninterrupted. 

This neck light comes with two light options on each of the arms: 1 LED for a flashlight mode, and the other one for a wide area flood light. Both of the arms have seperate switches on them, so you can only turn on the type of light you need at the moment.

At the same time, each of the arms have 3 brightness levels, from a slight light to an extremely bright light. Besides, these are rechargeable lights and has the lifespan of 1000 cycles, which is equal to more than 3000 pieces of AAA batteries. With a full charge, you can use these lamps for up to 40 hours of reading or working! 

Important Features:

  • Flexible neckband for wearing around the neck 
  • 2 LED lights on both sides of the neck 
  • 1 LED flashlight arm and 1 LED flood light arm 
  • Individual switches on both arms 
  • 3 brightness levels 
  • Rechargeable lamps can be used anywhere 
  • Can be used up to 40 hours with a single charge 
  • Can be used in places with no electricity 
  • Direction of light can be adjusted easily 
  • Lifespan of 1000 cycles 
  • Saves the cost of 3000 AAA batteries 
  • Soft silicone body 

4. LITOM 2019 Upgraded Office Desk Lamp

This desk lamp from LITOM can be perfect anywhere you want to read, work or continue your crafting projects. It can stand on a desk and needs a very small space for itself, and won’t add to the clutter of your desk.

You can even fold it up into an almost non-existing size when you don’t need it, put it inside a drawer for later. 

This lamp has a 180-degree flexible and moveable arm that you can swivel in any direction. The slick design and color will fit in completely with any room decor and style, and the lamp is available in both white and black body.

This lamp comes with 42 LED lights inside, which includes 14 cold white lights and 28 cold white lights, and will give you a non-flickering, soft light at all times. Your eyes will be rested and comfortable even when you work at night or for a long time without resting.

This lamp will be a positive change from any wall lights that can make your eyes tired and heavy; the LED lights in this lamp will actually take care of your eyes as you work. 

This lamp will last for more than 50,000 hours without you needing to change a single LED light bulb inside, and comes with a 25-year guarantee of no trouble. Besides, this lamp comes with a single on/off touch button and 3 brightness levels for different types of activities, as well as options for lightning mode change. 

Important Features:

  • Slick and modern design 
  • Stands on your craft table 
  • Can be folded and stored away when not needed 
  • 3 color modes 
  • 3 brightness levels 
  • 42 LED light sources (14 cold and 28 warm) 
  • Can be swiveled in any direction 
  • Soft, non-flickering, unobstructive light 
  • Protects and soothes your eyes while working 
  • Will last for more than 50,000 hours 
  • Won’t need a light bulb change in 25 years 
  • 20% less electricity consumption 
  • One touch on/off button 
  • Memory of personal setting 

5. Brightech Litespan Slim LED Floor Lamp  

The Litespan Slim is another LED floor lamp from Brightec with a long stand that you can use anywhere you are working. It is lightweight and easy to carry around with you in other rooms beside your craft room, if you feel the need to work someplace else.

It is a very bright lamp with a very precise light direction. You can use this lamp to illuminate your working space without bothering anyone else in the vicinity. 

The flexible gooseneck design allows you to bend and swivel the lamp in any way your want to - towards your work or away from it - whichever you need at the moment.

You can even use it beside your couch for a reading lamp, or in your bedroom. The warm 3000k yellow light is comfortable for your eyes, even when you work for hours at an end. This lamp has a bright 2,000 lumen brightness and a 6,000k cool white light and 4,500k mixture of yellow & white light. 

This lamp comes with a 12 watt LED light that actually saves electricity; so that, your electricity bill will be reduced than when using a regular light. Besides, the lamp comes with a lifetime guarantee so that you’ll never need to change a single light bulb inside it. 

Important Features:

  • Slick design with a long stand 
  • Flexible gooseneck can be folded, bend and swiveled 
  • Lightweight lamp can be carried around 
  • Warm 3,000k yellow light and 6,000k white light 
  • 4,500k mixture of both yellow and white light 
  • Comes with 12 watt LED lights 
  • Reduces electricity bill 
  • Lifetime guarantee of light bulbs 
  • Can be used as a reading light or at work 

6. Verilux Original SmartLight LED Floor Lamp

This LED floor lamp from Verilux will be great for not just your craft room, but anywhere in the house; for reading, writing or for a soft glow in your bedroom, you can definitely use this floor lamp anywhere and for anything.

The light and the color of the light can be adjusted according to your preference, and the natural daylight lighting of the lamp is soothing to the eyes. 

The lamp comes with long-lasting LED light bulbs inside that you’ll never have to change for an entire lifetime, and use for more than a few decades.  You can adjust the type and color of the lights, and choose from the multiple brightness options to dim the light according to your needs.

The adjustable gooseneck of the lamp makes it easier for you to point the light at any way you want to, simply by pivoting the lamp in your preferred direction. 

The light coming from the Verilux Original SmartLight resembles natural sunlight coming into your rooms, which can be available to you at any time of the day.

Whether you are reading, crafting, painting or sewing, you can get the best crafting light for the occasion, always. This is the updated version of the Verilux Original LED lamp that was first manufactured more than 60 years ago by Verilux. 

Important Features:

  • LED floor lamp 
  • Flexible gooseneck that can be bended and moved 
  • Provides a natural sunlight 
  • Multiple brightness levels to choose from 
  • Long lasting LED bulbs doesn’t need changing for decades 
  • Updated version of the classic Verilux Original Lamp 
  • Adjustable color temperature 
  • Strain-free, flicker-free light at all times 
  • Can be used for a long at a time 
  • Doesn’t increase electricity bill by a lot 

7. OttLite L139AB 13 Watt Desk Lamp    

The light from this 13 watt desk lamp from OttLite is a very small one, with a 19.5 inch height that can be folded into almost half its size. When not in use, you can simply fold it into a smaller size and keep it away in your drawer for later.

It also comes with a handle for ease of carying, since you can take it with you anywhere you feel like working. 

The base of the OttLite L139AB takes a very small space on your desk, and you can easily adjust the angle of the light up to 360-degree. The lamp comes with a 13 watt tube that will work uninterrupted for more than 10,000 hours, and can be changed later.

The flip lid of the lamp makes it easy for you to work with the light from this lamp without the glare getting to your eyes. You can simply keep the light facing downwards so that the light falls on your project on the table and not your eye. 

Important Features:

  • 13 watt tube 
  • Small and modern desk lamp 
  • Flip open and close for easy storing 
  • Comes with a handle for carrying 
  • Light head can be adjusted up to 360-degree 
  • Runs on electricity and comes with a cord 
  • Can be run for 10,000 hours without changing 
  • Bulbs can be changed when needed 

8. Brightech LightView Pro Flex 2-in-1 LED Lamp   

You’ll love the design on this modern lamp from Brightech, a LED table lamp with a slick and attractive design that will look great on your desk. This is something more than just a lamp, as the Brightech LightView also comes with a built-in glass magnifier, to help you in your delicate and acute craft projects.

You can use this magnifier when reading, painting, putting thread into your needles, or in similar crafts. The lens is made from a genuine 3” lens so it’s an actually magnifier, not the cheap ones you can usually find in the marker made from plastic or fiber.

Once you pull the lamp close to your project, you can use both your hands to do your work, because you won’t need to hold the magnifier with one. 

The base of the lamp is solid and heavy, and will stay standing on your desk even amidst all your other crafting supplies and organizers.

The gooseneck design of the lamp makes it possible to bring the light and the magnifier close to your project so that you can work better. You can also use the magnifier to read books with small fonts or put threads into needles. 

The light will always stay cool even after the lamp has been in use for hours, which eliminates the chances of accidental burning. You get a 6000k white natural daylight with this lamp, which is better for older people with failing eyesight. 

Important Features:

  • A lamp and a magnifier in one 
  • Hands-free magnifier for crafting, reading, sewing and painting 
  • 6000k white daylight lamp 
  • Thick 3” glass magnifier 
  • Solid and heavy base 
  • Gooseneck flexible design 
  • Lamp can be bent and moved in all directions 
  • Comes with a clamp

9. NAPATEK Smart LED Desk Lamp    

The design of this LED desk lamp is so unique, anyone might mistake it for a scientific instrument! Tall and slender, it comes in multiple color options and sits erect on your desk.

However, this Smart LED desk lamp is much more than just a lamp, as it also has other very important features such as Wi-Fi control, voice control, wireless charging and memory function. 

You can use this lamp on your craft table for more than the light it provides, such as: you’ll be able to control this lamp with your voice via Amazon Alexa Google Home. You can ask Alexa to turn on and off the lamp, as well as adjust brightness.

You can also control the lamp with an app on your smartphone, and schedule turning it on/off. This lamp comes with several brightness and color options, including Leisure mode, Reading mode, Candle ode, Color Temperature mode, PC mode, etc.

Also, it comes with a 10W Qi Wireless charger than you can use to charge your phone; all you need to do is to place your wireless enabled smartphone or gadget on the base of the lamp and it will start charging automatically. 

The NAPATEK Smart LED lamp has 64 LED light bulbs inside with 3 color modes and 6 separate brightness levels. The head of the lamp can be rotated 180-degree for the light to fall on exactly the point you need it to. You can also set a 30-minute auto shut-off function on this 

lamp as a reminder to stop working or if you want to use this lamp as a night-light. 

Important Features:

  • 64 LED lights inside the lamp 
  • 3 color options and 6 brightness levels 
  • Can be controlled via Amazon Alexa 
  • Can be controlled via app on smartphone 
  • Can be scheduled for a 30-minute auto shut off 
  • Can be used to charge phones with a wireless bluetooth on 
  • Same light can be controlled by multiple members of the family 
  • 10W Qi Wireless charger 
  • Comes with a USB charging port
  • 180-degree rotatable lamp head 
  • Memory function 
  • Slick, futuristic design 

10. OttLite K94CP3 3-in-1 Floor Lamp    

This design from OttLite is more than just a lamp; it also comes with an attached magnifier and a clamp. This is a 3-in-1 design that you can use in any of your hobbies, including painting, sewing, journalling and other crafts.

It is a floor lamp but the height can be adjusted to fit on your craft table or the side table beside your couch, or even in your bedroom. Wherever you are most comfortable working, you can carry this lamp with you. It is also compatible with a wheelbase, so that you can pull or push this floor lamp with you around the house. 

This is a 24-watt floor lamp in a champagne finish, excellent design that will look good anywhere in your home. The magnifier has a 5” diameter and is made of glass, not plastic or fiber.

The gooseneck design of the lamp, as well as the magnifier and the clamp, is flexible so that you can move them any way you want to. The clamp that comes with the lamp is capable of holding up instructions, designs, pictures and even some of your tools and utensils, keeping everything in front of you.  

The light bulbs inside the lamp can be used up to 10,000 hours and can be replaced when needed. The light you get is natural daylight, just what your eyes need when you are working on something delicate and minute. 

Important Features:

  • 3-in-1 lamp 
  • Adjustable height 
  • Can be used both as a floor lamp and a table top lamp 
  • Comes with a clamp and a magnifier 
  • 5” diameter magnifier made of glass 
  • Can be used with a wheelbase accessory 
  • Can be used up to 10,000 hours 
  • Bulbs can be replaced 

11. TOMOL Super Bright COB LED Desk Lamp

This is a tiny little desk lamp from TOMOL, one that you can easily put back into a drawer or into your bag, carry it around with you. This lamp is a battery operated lamp, which means that you can use it in the garden, patio or your backyard, or even take it with you to hikes, camping and picnic.

The light is extremely bright, and has three levels that you can choose from. As a matter of fact, this lamp can be about 3 times brighter than any regular desk lamp. 

Folded, this desk lamp becomes only 5” in length, 3” in breadth and 1.75” in height. It comes with a USB cord for you to charge this lamp with, but can also run with 4 AA batteries. The lamp is touch sensitive; you can turn it on/off and adjust the brightness with a single touch. 

Important Features:

  • Mini desk lamp that can be folded into 5” x 3” x 1.75” 
  • Touch sensitive operation 
  • Runs on batteries 
  • Can be carried and used anywhere 
  • 3 brightness levels 
  • Adjustable neck position 
  • Comes with a USB cable 
  • 220 lumens of light 
  • Natural white light 
  • Upgraded design and output 
  • 3 times brighter than regular desk lamps 
  • Can fit into your bag, purse or pocket 

These were the 11 best desk or floor lamps that you can find in the market these days. One or more of these can be the perfect one for your craft room, for your work table, or any other places in your home, even your bedroom and living room. 

Craft Lights Buying Guide: Features to Look For 

Buying the best crafts light cannot be too difficult, but there are a number of features that you need to look for in one. The features in most craft lights and lamps are similar to each other, but some of them feature a few extra details that can prove to be very helpful for you.

These features are what you need to look for when settling on a particular model for your home

  1. Light Modes

Most of the lamps come with more than one light modes, i.e. they usually have options to choose between white lights, yellow lights, warm lights, cold lights, daylight, etc. With bulbs and lamps these days, you won’t have to choose between a particular type of light, because they have multiple options for you. 

For example, the Brightech Litespan LED Reading and Craft Floor Lamp and the TaoTronics LED Desk Lamp has 5 color modes to choose from, and both the LITOM 2019 Upgraded Office Desk Lamp and the NAPATEK Smart LED Desk Lamp has 3 color modes.

You get options of different color types with these lamps, so that you can choose the one that appeals to you or the one that is required for your project at hand. 

  1. Brightness Levels

Just as you get options for different color modes with lamps these days, you can also adjust the brightness level to several tones.

With the TOMOL Super Bright COB LED Desk Lamp and LITOM 2019 Upgraded Office Desk Lamp, you get 3 brightness levels to choose from; on the other hand, with the TaoTronics LED Desk Lamp and the NAPATEK Smart LED Desk Lamp, you get 7 brightness levels and 6 brightness levels for you to choose from. 

There are many advantages that all these brightness levels you get in these crafting lamps. You can get a light as strong as natural daylight with the highest brightness level, or a subtle nightlight that you can keep on throughout the night on the lowest level.

The more levels you have to choose from, the more versatile your lamp becomes. You can watch the same brand and model all around the house, for decor in your living room and watching television, for cooking and working on your projects and crafts, as well as for a reading lamp or a night light in your bedroom. 

  1. Flexibility

With decorative lamps, you don’t need them to be flexible, because they are supposed to be straight and fixed at one point. However, with work lamps and craft table lamps, you need them to be flexible, so that you can bend and move the lamps any way you want to so that the light focuses on your project at hand. 

Some craft lamps, such as the Brightech Litespan LED Reading and Craft Floor Lamp, 

the Brightech Litespan Slim LED Floor Lamp and the Verilux Original SmartLight LED Floor Lamp come with flexible goosenecks that you can simply twist, bend and fold in any shape, so that the light directly falls on whatever you are working on. 

Other craft lamps are also flexible, but instead of a gooseneck, are made of multiple straight parts that you can bend and twist, swivel and lower in multiple directions and angles, such as the TaoTronics LED Desk Lamp, the LITOM 2019 Upgraded Office Desk Lamp and the  OttLite L139AB 13 Watt Desk Lamp.

These lamps can also be folded into a small size and stored away until you need them again. 

  1. Size

Craft lamps come in all sizes, heights and shapes. Some are big enough to stand on your floor and give light on your tables, while other designs are small enough to carry around in your bag or pocket, or keep stored away in your drawers.

The Brightech Litespan LED Reading and Craft Floor Lamp and the Brightech Litespan Slim LED Floor Lamp are both rather large floor lamps while the TOMOL Super Bright COB LED Desk Lamp is small enough to fold and put inside your bag or store away in a drawer.

On the other hand, the Vekkia Rechargeable 4 LED Book Light is a miniature lamp that you can actually wear around your neck. 

  1. Special Parts and/or Features

Sometimes, your craft lamp can come with some additional parts or features that will be extremely helpful in your projects, such as the OttLite K94CP3 3-in-1 Floor Lamp that comes with both a magnifier and a clamp.

You can use the magnifier to work on complicated and detailed projects and the clamp to hold your designs, instructions or even tools. The Brightech LightView Pro Flex 2-in-1 LED Lamp also comes with a magnifier built into the lamp.

The magnifier with this lamp is a 3” glass one that rivals the quality of any other magnifying glass in the marker, not a cheap replica of plastic and fiber ones. 

The NAPATEK Smart LED Desk Lamp, on the other hand, is a smart LED desk lamp. It comes with special features such as wireless charging for your phone, voice control options via Amazon Alexa and Google Home, and smartphone app control options.

You can schedule this lamp to turn on and off or even dim, with your phone, so that you don’t come home to a dark home in the evening. The OttLite K94CP3 3-in-1 Floor Lamp can be used both as a floor lamp and a desk lamp, as you can adjust its height. These are the special features that makes these lamps different from others. 

  1. Electricity Consumption

All of these lamps contain LED lights, which means that they consume very little electricity. You can use these lamps for hours at an end, every day, and your electricity bill won’t increase a lot. 

  1. Other Important Features

Some of the other features that can be important in a craft lamp includes: 

  • Number of lumen outputs; 
  • Number of LED bulbs in the lamp; 
  • Whether the lamp gets hot with use;
  • Whether it is lightweight enough to carry around the house; 
  • Whether the bulbs can be changed; 
  • How many years the bulbs would last without replacing;
  • Whether the design takes up a lot of space; 
  • Whether the design and color blends in with your decor; 
  • Whether they are rechargeable or runs on batteries; 
  • Non-flickering lights; 
  • Personal memory setting, etc 

Though these features aren’t very important to the quality of the lamp, they can be nice inclusions that can make your working experience better. 

So now that you know about all the important features that should be present in a craft lamp, it all comes down to the price. Craft tables come at different prices, depending on the brand, size and features.

The one that fits your budget should ideally have all the features you need in a craft lamp for your projects, which isn’t very hard to find. 

Using Craft Lights and Lamps

Anyone who loves to sew, paint, or craft requires almost 3 to 5 times the light we generally do in our lives. Craft lamps and craft lights are extremely important for them in their work, but these lamps can also be used in other chores and projects around the house. 

Using a craft light isn’t very different from using any other lamp in your house. Most of the time, regular lamps are decorative pieces around the house, placed strategically to illuminate a specific part of the house.

Sometimes, lamps are placed on work tables and beside your favorite couches for reading or drawing, painting, sketching, cutting projects etc. Craft lamps, on the other hand, are actually special lamps used on or beside your crafting table to give direct light to the project you are working on. 

Craft lights are placed as close to your project as possible, and they often have a flexible gooseneck or can be bent and swiveled so that you can fix the light on the part of your table or project that you are working on.

Besides, craft lights are usually brighter than regular lamps and give you direct light, brighter than natural daylight or sunlight, so that you can keep on working at nights and evenings. 

Most craft lamps also come with brightness and color options, so that you’ll be able to use the same lamp for different purposes. With the highest level of brightness, you can work on your projects better, even at nights; at the same time, you can use the low brightness levels as a nightlight for your bedrooms.

Since all these lamps contain LED lights, your electricity bill wouldn’t increase very much, even if you use these lamps all day and all night long. 

At the same time, you don’t need to do much to take care of you craft lamps and lights. They need to be kept clean at all times, and you should take care that you don’t drop water or any other liquid on them.

If your craft lamp is right in front of an open window, you need to make sure it doesn’t get wet by incoming rain. If your lamp gets soaked in rain water, it could cause short circuit for your whole house, and that will be dangerous. 

Also, it is important that your craft lamp doesn’t get direct sunlight, especially at midday when the sun is at their brightest and strongest. This may damage the delicate LED lights and the controls of these lamps, as they are most suited to cool environments and shades. 

Your craft lamp doesn’t need a lot of electricity to run, but if they are battery operated and/or rechargeable, you should take care to charge it often and also change the batteries whenever needed.

Just like any other gadgets, your lamp’s charge shouldn’t drop below a dangerous level before you put it to charge. It might damage the internal batteries of your lamp if you let it fall down to a dangerously low charge often.

At the same time, you should change the batteries of your battery-operated lamp as often as needed, and not mix old batteries with new ones. 

Beside keeping your craft lamps clean, there isn’t much more to do to maintain them. If used right, some of these lamps can go up to decades without needing change of bulbs or repairs. 

Conclusion  

The right lamp can make a world of difference to your craft. When you are working at night and don’t want to disturb anyone else, or if you prefer to work in the afternoons but need a good light, one of these crafting lamps are just what you need.

They are all extremely useful and efficient, and will keep on giving you bright daylight anytime of the day, making your job easier for you. 

Alex John
 

This is Alex, I have been in tshirt business for the last eight years. This is my blog where I share my work and guidelines for fellows. Keep reading resources from here and I am open to any question.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: